|
The 80th HASTINGS INTERNATIONAL CHESS CONGRESS will
take place at Horntye Park in Hastings from 28th
December 2004 and 9th January 2005.
Due to the fact that there are inadequate funds
available for both a Premier and Challengers separately this year,
and yet people wanted both to continue, there had to be a radical
solution. Several people came up with different aspects of this,
including Mark Bryant, Dr Dirk Jordan (Germany), David Welch and
myself.
Comments on the system can be found at the conclusion of the
regulation.
THE HASTINGS SYSTEM
-
The
players shall be placed in the order of the draw in FIDE
Rating order in the normal way. Unrated players shall be
placed in order of their perceived playing strength, below all
rated players.
-
The
pairings shall be top half v second half. If there is an odd
number, the player held back shall be the median. The players
shall play a one round knockout.
-
If
a player wins a match at any stage of the knockout by default,
he shall proceed to the next round, having won that game
without colour.
-
The
draw for who has White in the first game shall be made at the
Opening Party 27 December at 10pm at Horntye Park. Colours
will then alternate going down the list in the usual way.
-
If
12 player come from Belarus as is expected, they will not be
paired together in Round 1, nor will two members of the same
close family relationship.
-
If
a player misses the first round, he shall be placed in the
second round of the Challengers with a ½ with no colour.
-
The
rate of play shall be 40 moves in the first 70 minutes for
White and 90 minutes for Black, plus 20 minutes extra for all
the remaining moves; adding on one minute per move from the
first. This shall apply throughout all rounds in both
tournaments.
-
If
the first game is drawn, play-offs will not commence before 30
minutes after the conclusion of the first game or 6.30pm,
unless agreed otherwise with the arbiter. Particularly in the
first round, it will be advantageous if the start times are
staggered.
-
If
the first game is drawn, there shall be a two game mini-match.
The rate of play shall be all the moves in 10 minutes plus 10
seconds for every move from the first. Whoever had White in
the first game shall have Black in the second. There shall be
a 10 minute break between games, unless agreed otherwise with
the arbiter.
-
If
the mini-match is drawn, there shall be an Armageddon
play-off. This game shall not commence until 15 minutes after
the conclusion of the mini-match, or 8pm, unless otherwise
agreed with the arbiter. There shall be a new drawing of lots.
White shall receive six minutes and Black five minutes, with
no increment. Black will go through to the next round of the
knockout if this game is drawn.
-
Every
effort must be made to reconstruct the speed games with the
help of the two players, who shall be expected to co-operate
after the match is finished. If there is only one arbiter for
an Armageddon, he shall make no attempt to keep score.
-
Results
of games shall be posted as best as possible. There shall be
no attempt to conceal the information from players still in
play.
-
Unless
there are precisely 128 or 64 players, there will have to be
lucky losers. These shall be selected first:
-
From
players who drew, their first game.
-
Choosing
players who best balance the colours, after that
-
Where
there is still a need for selection, from the highest
ranking pairing in order. Thus, if the requirement is of
players who had Black in the first round then, if the lower
rated player had Black, he shall be selected rather than the
higher rated who had White.
-
Let
us assume there are 64 players left after round 1 after the
lucky losers have been utilised. Then, if the lower rated
player won on Board 5, he takes on the 5th seed position, just
as in a normal knockout. Due to late entries, the board
numbers may be displaced. This shall be corrected, according
to the rank of the higher rated player.
-
The
lucky losers shall be placed at the bottom of the rankings in
order of their round 1 ranking.
-
The
Round 2 pairing shall be top half v second half in ranking
order. Let us assume there is a colour imbalance 34 White
seekers, 30 Black seekers. Then the first 30 pairings shall be
with the correct colours, promoting two players from the White
seeking side to the Black seeking side if necessary. The
bottom four White seekers shall be paired together. The
position of the two higher ranking White seekers shall be
retained and the two lower ranking White seekers moved
opposite them.
The first time this happens, the extra White shall be given
first to the player who won the first game, then to one who
was knocked out in the Armageddon, then to one who was knocked
out in the two game match, then to the lower ranking player.
The colour then alternates for each subsequent pairing where
both players were eliminated at the same stage.
If there is a preponderance of Black seekers, then the reverse
procedure shall be followed. Where both players are due Black
and were eliminated at the same stage, then the extra White
will be awarded to the higher ranking player.
-
The
players who have qualified for the second round of the
knockout shall be announced as soon as possible after the
conclusion of the last game.
-
The
pairings for the Knockout and challengers shall be displayed,
but not before 9.30pm.
-
Two
arbiters (or pairs) shall do the second round draw
independently.
-
Players
who are knocked out shall then join the Challengers. Those who
drew their first game shall have ½ point and are placed in
rating order. Those who lost have 0 points and are also placed
in rating order. It makes no difference at which stage the
player is knocked out.
-
Round
2 29 December. The 64 players shall play a knockout as in
round 1.
-
Players
may not be paired together twice in the Knockout until the
final, nor ever in the Challengers.
-
Round
3 30 December. The 32 players shall play a knockout as for
round 1. Their ranking positions shall not be altered,
irrespective of their rating.
-
The
32 losers shall join the Challengers with a score of ½, 1 or
1½.
-
Round
4 31 December. The 16 players shall play a knock-out as
before. The remaining 104 players are in the Challengers.
-
Round
5 1-2 January. There are 8 players left in the knockout and
this becomes referred to as The Premier. Pairings are strictly
1-5, 2-6, 3-7, 4-8, no player may meet the same opponent twice
except in the final.
-
The
players play a two game match. The colours for the first game
shall be decided after the pairings are made. If both players
have the same colour history, there shall be a drawing of
lots. Tied matches shall be resolved as before.
-
The
Premier semi-finals take place 3-4 January.
-
The
final shall take place 5-6 January.
-
If
the match in the final is drawn, the two players shall play as
in the tie-breaking system. There shall be a winner who takes
first prize.
-
Players
are never allowed to take a ½ point bye while playing in the
knockout.
-
If
a player defaults in the Premier after one game, his opponent
shall qualify to the next stage. The defaulting player shall
not be allowed to play in the Challengers except under
exceptional circumstances, nor will he receive any prize money
unless withdrawing for reasons beyond his control; such as
certified ill-health or death of a close family member.
-
If
a player withdraws from the knockout before the pairings have
been displayed, from round 2 to game 8, he shall be replaced
by a lucky loser. Once the pairings have been displayed s/he
shall not be replaced.
-
No
defaulting player shall receive any prize money in either
tournament, unless his/her entry was accepted before the
tournament on the basis that he would withdraw at the
pre-announced stage.
COMMENTS
(6).
Having all the top players in the same section at the start has
the advantage that not as many grandmasters are needed for players
to achieve title norms. Thus there is a financial saving.
(7).
In a one game knockout, White would normally have a tremendous
advantage. By using the time handicap, we hope to eradicate this.
Approximately the same number of people has said it is too little
as has said it is too much. No statistics are available.
One advantage of a knockout is that eventually there must be a
decisive game. There is little doubt that it is the ‘fairest’
system.
Some people have been surprised that the time handicap is used
throughout the event. I am surprised that anybody considered it
could be any other way. If players reverted to 80 minutes for both
players after the first round, then one player might have a
disadvantage in that first round and it not be balanced by the
second. A player eliminated from the knockout, would have to play
at a different time rate from his next opponent. Thus he would be
at a disadvantage from the third round.
(13).
The lucky loser system is extremely difficult to get correct.
There is no ‘correct’ answer.
(23).
From round 3 it is possible there will be a dreadful imbalance of
colours. It is possible a player will have 3 Whites and one Black,
or vice versa, after round 4 and that this will never be
corrected. This is also possible in any Swiss; we rely on White
only achieving a slightly higher percentage than Black. The
knock-on effect is that somebody eliminated in the semi-final,
might get two Whites or two blacks in the Challengers in the last
two rounds. Presumably nobody has ever thought of giving
differential time to White and Black before. It makes perfect
sense for any tournament other than a double round all-play-all.
A
player could deliberately lose in the play-off in the semis in
order to secure the first £800 prize in the Challengers and £400
in the Premier. He would be foolish to do so. He would be forgoing
his chance of winning the £1500 first prize in the Premier or
receiving the runner-up award of £1000 and even 7/8 would not
secure him a certain first prize in the Challengers.
It
is unlikely we have considered all possible snags. Thus the right
is reserved to make minor amendments to these rules.
It
is interesting that Russian State TV Canal Sport is sending a crew
to Hastings to cover the event. This is the first time Russian TV
has ever done anything like this. The working title is ‘Elmira
comes to Hastings’.
Stewart
Reuben
|